No one counted the 16,621 jobs blamed on sugar tax.

The sugar industry cites it in its campaign to scrap South Africa’s Health Promotion Levy.

It is a model’s estimate for 2019 against a no-levy scenario, the Treasury says, not an audited count.

A 2025 study of national labour surveys found no significant link between the levy and sugar-sector employment.

Canegrowers urge Finance Minister Enoch Godongwana to scrap the levy, and the Treasury has commissioned no jobs study.

How each outlet framed it
Daily Maverick leans critical
tests the 16,621-jobs figure against the Treasury's confirmation that it is a CGE model estimate, not a count of lost jobs

Sources: Daily Maverick